Dark Humour and Resilience: Why We Laugh When Things Feel Unsafe

Part 2/4 of the What Laughter Knows series.

There’s a particular kind of joke that only works when things are genuinely bad.

You've heard it. You may have made it. It arrives in the middle of something frightening or exhausting or bleak. It’s not especially clever, and it shouldn't land the way it does. Yet the room shifts.

That’s the laugh this post is about. The one that knows what it's up against.

Not Cruelty. Not Escape. Something Else.

Call it dark humour or call it gallows humour; both get used, and neither quite fits. What they miss is that this kind of laughter is almost always apologised for, as though finding something funny in the middle of difficulty were proof of not feeling it deeply enough.

But that isn't indifference. More often it's the opposite.

It's what happens when people who care deeply have nowhere to put it.

It’s the joke the nurse makes at the end of a long shift. It’s the absurd observation shared between two people sitting with a genuinely difficult situation, neither of them pretending it’s anything other than what it is. It’s humour that has looked at the thing directly and chosen not to look away, but to find within it something briefly, darkly, honestly funny.

Viktor Frankl, the psychiatrist and Holocaust survivor, wrote about encountering this in conditions far worse than most of us will ever face. Similar moments of humour appear even in everyday therapy, when someone describing something heavy finds a moment of humour in the middle of it, not to dismiss it, but to make contact with it differently.

Frankl called humour one of the soul's weapons. You begin to understand why when you see it happen, when someone laughs, briefly, in the middle of something difficult.

Nothing about the difficulty disappears, but something else comes into view alongside it: a small sign that you are still there, not entirely overtaken.

Still Capable of This

The other thing worth noticing about the laugh that knows what it's up against is that it’s almost never solitary.

Think about it. The jokes you remember from the hardest periods of your life, or the hardest days of a difficult job, were almost certainly shared with someone. They happened between people. They required, at some level, that both of you understood what was being acknowledged. That mutual recognition of the thing being held between you is itself a form of intimacy.

When two people laugh together in the middle of something frightening, something significant passes between them. It’s a signal, a recognition. I see what you see. I feel what you feel. And here we are, still standing, still capable of this. There’s solidarity in that. A kind of companionship that goes beyond reassurance or comfort because it does not require either person to pretend.

This is why humour and resilience are connected. Shared laughter, particularly the dark and honest kind, reminds us that we are not alone in what we are carrying. And that reminder, it turns out, changes things.

The Humour That Keeps You Yourself

When everything feels serious, there's a pressure to become a smaller and more serious version of yourself. The part of you that struggles or grieves gets all the attention, and rightly so. But there's a lighter part that comes under pressure too, one that tends to go unnoticed.

You know the part: the one that finds the absurd in the serious and the serious in the absurd.

Setting that part of yourself aside can feel understandable, even responsible. But over time it costs something. The self that laughs isn't a lesser self. It may be the most honestly human one, the part that can sit with something hard and still, somehow, find it a little funny.

When you laugh in the middle of something genuinely difficult, you are not escaping it. You are refusing to be entirely consumed by it.

This is borne out by the research. The kind of humour oriented toward shared human imperfection rather than toward any target tends to protect people against depression and anxiety. What you laugh at, and with whom, turns out to matter.

To keep your sense of humour during difficult times isn't a coping strategy. It’s one of the ways people stay whole.

Something to Carry with You

Not all laughter pulls people together, and it's worth saying so plainly.

There's a difference between the humour that acknowledges a shared difficulty and the humour that makes someone the target of it. Research on humour styles consistently finds the same distinction: the kind directed at a shared situation tends to protect people, while the kind directed at a person tends to corrode.

The first draws a circle that includes everyone in the room. The second draws one that leaves someone standing outside it. Most of us have felt both, and we know the difference in our bodies before we know it in our minds.

The laughter this series is concerned with is the first kind. The kind that sustains people through hard times, that keeps something human intact when everything is pressing in. The kind that says: we are in this together, and for this one moment, we are going to find it, against all the odds, just a little bit funny.

The next time you find yourself laughing at something that feels as though it shouldn't be funny, pay attention to what that laughter is doing. Where it's coming from, who it's connecting you to, and what part of you it's keeping alive.

It doesn't mean you are not taking things seriously.

It may be a sign that you are taking them seriously with your whole self. And that includes the parts of you that still know how to laugh.

What Laughter Knows is a series written for anyone navigating uncertainty and wondering how to stay well within it. Written from a humanistic, person-centred perspective by a practising psychotherapist.

For more information, visit Inner Counsel Psychotherapy.

#Resilience #PsychotherapyLife #DarkHumour #TorontoTherapist

© 2024-2026 Stefan Jurgens. All rights reserved.

Unless otherwise noted, all content on this blog is the copyright of Stefan Jurgens.