The Problem With New Year’s Resolutions (And a Kinder Way Forward)

Did you know that most New Year's resolutions are abandoned by mid-February? If yours is one of them, you're not weak or undisciplined. The problem isn't you. The problem is the entire concept of resolutions.

The Hidden Flaw in Traditional Resolutions

Here's what most of us do: We make grand declarations on January 1st. We promise to transform ourselves completely. Then, at the first slip, we turn inward with harsh criticism. "What's wrong with me? Why can't I just stick to this?"

That voice can feel like it’s pushing us toward change. In reality, it does the opposite.

When we respond to setbacks with self-criticism, we drain the motivation we need to keep going, trading effort for shame. However, if we respond to ourselves with kindness, we create the emotional safety that makes trying again feel possible.

It seems counter-intuitive. Shouldn't being hard on ourselves motivate us? It doesn't.

Why Self-Compassion Works Better Than New Year’s Resolutions

A few years ago, I decided I'd hit the gym five days a week. By January 10th, I'd gone twice and felt like a failure. Instead of giving up, I asked myself, “What would actually work?” I realized movement was already happening in my life. I just needed to notice it and count it instead of dismissing anything that wasn't a formal gym session.

That shift, from command to curiosity, changed everything.

This is what self-compassion actually looks like. It's not about lowering standards or making excuses. It's about responding to yourself the way you'd respond to a good friend who's struggling.

When someone you care about tells you they've broken their resolution, you don't say, "You're so lazy. You'll never change." You say something like, "That's tough. What made it hard? How can we adjust this so it actually works for you?"

That’s the voice that creates change. Not the harsh inner critic, but the one willing to stay open and adaptable when things don’t go as planned.

The Three Elements That Make Self-Compassion for New Year's Change Possible

Self-compassion might sound abstract, but it comes down to three practices you can use right now.

The first is mindfulness. Notice what you're feeling without exaggerating or ignoring it. "I'm frustrated that I didn't exercise today" is mindful. "I'm a complete failure" is not. The difference matters because you can work with frustration. Failure feels permanent.

The second is common humanity. Your struggle isn't evidence that something is uniquely wrong with you. Everyone finds change difficult. The person at the gym who never misses a workout? They struggled to build that habit too. You're not broken. You're human.

The third is self-kindness. Speak to yourself with the same warmth you'd offer someone you care about. When things get hard, ask yourself: "What do I need right now?" Not "What should I be doing?" or "Why can't I get this right?" Just "What do I need?"

These three elements create the emotional safety that makes genuine change possible.

When you feel safe with yourself, trying again doesn't feel like risking another failure. It just feels like the next step.

What to Do Instead of Making Resolutions

So what do you do instead? Here are four approaches that work with your nature rather than against it.

Start impossibly small. Not "exercise five times a week" but "put on workout clothes twice this week." Not "meditate daily" but "take three conscious breaths when I wake up." Small actions compound over time. They also don't trigger the resistance that dramatic changes create. When something feels manageable, you're more likely to actually do it.

Shift from doing to being. Instead of "I will go to the gym," try "I'm becoming someone who values movement." This identity-based approach changes your relationship with the goal itself. You're not forcing yourself to act against your nature. You're allowing your nature to evolve. The difference is subtle but powerful.

Focus on now, not later. Resolutions live in the future. Intentions live in this moment. Ask yourself: How do I want to show up today? What matters to me right now? That present-moment awareness is where real change begins. You can't control next month, but you can choose how you respond to this moment.

Build on what already works. Attach new habits to existing ones. If you already make coffee each morning, that's your cue for three minutes of stillness. If you already walk to your car, that's when you take five deep breaths. Your brain loves connecting new behaviours to established patterns. It's easier than starting from scratch.

Why It Matters Now

January doesn't arrive in a vacuum. It follows months of strain, uncertainty, and exhaustion. We're often operating on reserve, not surplus. Trying to reinvent yourself from that place isn't just difficult, it's setting yourself up for the very self-criticism that makes change impossible.

This year, what if you started from where you actually are? Tired, maybe. Uncertain, perhaps. But also here, now, with the capacity to notice what's true and respond with kindness.

You don't need to become someone new to take the next step. You can begin exactly as you are, treating yourself the way you'd treat anyone you love who's trying their best.

Maybe this year doesn't need a resolution. Maybe it just needs your gentle attention and your openness to speak to yourself like someone who deserves compassion.

Because you do.

If you'd like support in exploring this gentler approach to change, that's what therapy offers. Reach out when you're ready.

#NewYearsResolutions #SelfCompassion #TorontoTherapist #LawyersOfToronto #FinanceProfessionals #DowntownToronto

© 2025 Stefan Jurgens. All rights reserved.

Unless otherwise noted, all content on this blog is the copyright of Stefan Jurgens.