When Your Inner Critic Won't Shut Up: Learning to Soften the Voice Inside
- Stefan Jurgens
- Jan 13
- 4 min read
I used to lie awake at 2 a.m., replaying conversations from earlier that day, convinced I'd said something stupid or disappointing.
My mind would compile evidence like a prosecuting attorney: the awkward pause, the forced laugh, the way someone looked away. "See?" the voice would say. "You're not good enough."
For years, I thought this was just who I was. Turned out, it was just a story I'd learned to believe.
That relentless inner dialogue, those harsh self-judgments, the sense of being stuck in the same patterns despite your best efforts? You're not alone in this experience.
Why This Matters Now
Anxiety, burnout, perfectionism, and chronic self-criticism often have less to do with what's happening around us and more to do with what's happening inside us.
The cost is real: it shows up as exhaustion, hesitation, and a gnawing sense that we're falling short.
But here's what matters: when we notice these inner stories and self-talk patterns, we can begin responding to them with more flexibility, compassion, and resilience.
The Inner Stories We Tell Ourselves (and Why They Stick)
Negative self-narratives often start small: a missed deadline, an awkward interaction, or a lingering critical comment.
Over time, these moments get stitched into a broader conclusion about who we are.
"I made a mistake" becomes "I'm incompetent."
"I felt anxious" becomes "I'm weak."
This shift from behaviour to identity is subtle but powerful. The problem stops being something we experience and becomes something we are.
Our brains are wired with a negativity bias, a survival mechanism designed to detect threats. In modern life, this bias can turn inward. An uncomfortable memory or imagined rejection can trigger the same stress response as a real danger, making these stories feel convincing and automatic.
Understanding this doesn't erase the stories, but it helps us hold them with perspective.
They aren't evidence of failure. They're evidence of a system trying to keep us safe, even when it's no longer helpful.
Inner Voices: The Characters Behind the Stories
If inner stories are the arcs we live inside, inner voices are the characters that keep them alive.
Common ones include the Critical Voice that points out flaws and predicts failure, the Taskmaster or Perfectionist that pushes relentlessly, the Fearful Voice that urges caution or withdrawal, and sometimes a Compassionate or Wise Voice that offers care and steadiness.
These aren't signs something is wrong. They're attempts to manage risk, belonging, and survival. Problems arise when one voice, often the critic, dominates. When that happens, our inner world narrows.
When you can name the critic as "the critic" rather than "me," something shifts.
It's no longer "I'm not good enough." It becomes "the critic is saying I'm not good enough." That small shift creates just enough space to ask: Do I agree with this? Is this the story I want to live inside?
Change comes from realizing you can listen to these voices without letting them decide.
Creating Distance Without Denial
One meaningful shift is learning to separate who we are from what we experience.
"I am anxious" becomes "Anxiety is present right now."
"I am broken" becomes "I'm experiencing pain or uncertainty."
This isn't wordplay. It's externalization. When you externalize the experience, you create space between yourself and the problem.
You're no longer defined by it. Instead, you become the person who can observe it, question it, and choose how to respond to it.
Anxiety stops being your identity and becomes something you're in relationship with. And when you're in relationship with something rather than defined by it, you have choices about how to respond.
Look for exceptions to your harshest inner story: moments when you stayed present in a difficult conversation, offered care to yourself while struggling, or moved forward despite fear.
These aren't random. They're evidence of alternative storylines where you have agency, strength, and capacity.
When you notice these exceptions, you're not just observing. You're gathering material for a different story about who you are.
A Practical Approach: Therapeutic Letter-Writing
Insight alone rarely leads to lasting change.
One practical method is therapeutic letter-writing. Unlike free journaling, this involves writing to something: a part of yourself, a challenging experience, or an inner critic. Writing externalizes thoughts and emotions, creating space for reflection.
Try brief letters to an inner critic or anxious part, a younger or future self, or a situation you feel stuck in.
Even a few minutes can shift how overwhelming an inner experience feels.
The Invitation Forward
You are not your harshest thought.
You are not the story formed during a difficult season. You are a person with an inner world shaped by experience, and you can learn to relate to that world in new ways.
Meeting your inner stories and voices with understanding, rather than force, allows change to unfold. Slowly, imperfectly, but with kindness, flexibility, and room to breathe.
This is the work: not fixing what's broken, but discovering what becomes possible when you meet yourself with understanding instead of force.
If you'd like support in exploring your inner stories and voices, I offer a space to do this work together. You can book a consultation at Inner Counsel Psychotherapy.
© 2026 Stefan Jurgens. All rights reserved.
Unless otherwise noted, all content on this blog is the copyright of Stefan Jurgens.
Comments