The Silent Cost of Legal Excellence: A Look at Mental Health in Law

I spent nearly 20 years as a law librarian, and let me tell you - there's something we need to talk about. Behind the polished offices, power suits, and prestigious firm names, many professionals involved in the legal field are struggling. I've seen it firsthand: the associate who hasn't left the office before midnight in weeks, the litigator who can't sleep before big court dates, the paralegal trying to handle everything alone, and the in-house counsel juggling impossible deadlines.

Let’s be honest, law tends to attract a certain type of person. Brilliant minds, perfectionists, those with an incredible attention to detail. These qualities make for exceptional legal professionals, but they also come with a cost. The growing number of articles in publications like Canadian Lawyer makes it clear: Legal professionals experience depression and anxiety at significantly higher rates than the general population.

The numbers are sobering. According to the Federation of Law Societies of Canada, the pressure-cooker environment of legal practice is taking a devastating toll. After nearly two decades in the legal field, I saw firsthand how stress, burnout, and unhealthy coping mechanisms affected those around me. Witnessing so many talented professionals struggle—often in silence—helped me recognize the critical importance of mental health support. It’s one of the reasons I transitioned to a career as a psychotherapist: to help professionals find healthier ways to navigate the demands of their work.

So, who’s struggling the most? I saw the same patterns play out time and again: new associates drowning to meet billable hours, solo practitioners juggling the roles of lawyer, accountant, and office manager, and litigators shouldering the immense weight of high-profile cases. But the pressure doesn’t stop there. It ripples through entire organizations—legal assistants racing to meet court deadlines, paralegals balancing the demands of multiple attorneys. And we need to acknowledge another reality: lawyers from marginalized communities often face additional challenges, navigating systemic barriers on top of the profession’s already intense pressures. The stress manifests in different ways for different people, but one thing is clear: no one is immune.

Here's what worries me most. I see the same patterns repeat themselves. Perhaps it's an unspoken rule that you need to be at your desk well into the evening (even if you're just scrolling through emails), working with upsetting subject matter, or dealing with difficult clients, for example. And many of us can feel pressured to suppress our emotions, fearing that acknowledging stress will be seen as a weakness. And too often, alcohol or other substances become a go-to coping mechanism. The 2024 BMJ Public Health study entitled “Mental health effects of working as a legal professional in the field of asylum law: A systematic review” underscores just how widespread these unhealthy coping mechanisms have become in the legal profession.

The solution isn't always grand gestures or complete career overhauls. Sometimes it's as simple as giving yourself permission to breathe. Take those five minutes between client calls instead of immediately jumping into the next fire. Arrange to take a mental health day. Or consider talking to a therapist who gets it, who understands what it means to work in an environment where perfection isn't just expected, it's demanded. These small steps might feel insignificant, but they add up to something powerful: a sustainable way to practice law without losing yourself in the process. Reach out, I'm here.

The landscape is slowly shifting, and it's about time. These days, I'm seeing law firms wake up to reality - introducing mental health policies which actually mean something, embracing flexible work arrangements, and finally admitting that burnout is more than just "having a rough week." Organizations like the Law Society of Ontario (#LSOlawyer, #LSOparalegal) are stepping up with practical resources for reflective practice, while mental health practices, like my own Inner Counsel Psychotherapy, offer support tailored for legal professionals. Let's be clear - these aren't just trendy workplace perks. In today's legal environment, they're as essential as access to research databases, precedent files, and case management software.

There's something inspiring happening with the newer generation in law. They're quietly revolutionizing the profession, questioning the "live to work" mindset that burned out so many before them. I love watching them set clear boundaries around their time, openly discuss mental health challenges, and push back against the notion that success requires sacrifice of everything else. They're proving that you can be an outstanding legal professional without giving up your life outside the office. It's a refreshing shift from the old days when sending emails at 3 AM was seen as a badge of honour rather than a red flag.

From my years in law libraries, watching brilliant legal minds push themselves to the breaking point, I've learned one crucial lesson: taking care of your mental health isn't just some fluffy self-care trend - it's essential for survival in the legal field. The research backs this up: legal professionals who prioritize their mental health report better job satisfaction, stronger client relationships, and fewer ethical complaints.

Here's my challenge to you: start small, but start somewhere. Maybe it's scheduling regular check-ins with a mentor. Perhaps it's finally using those vacation days you've been hoarding. Or maybe it's just admitting to yourself that it's okay to not be okay sometimes. Small changes, when implemented consistently, can make a significant difference in mental well-being.

What about you? How do you handle the pressure of your practice? I'd love to hear your thoughts and strategies. The more we talk about this, the more we normalize prioritizing mental health. Your experience might be exactly what another legal professional needs to hear to feel less alone.

Let's keep this conversation going. Your career in law shouldn't cost you your well-being. And that's not just my opinion, that's a fact backed by growing research and real-world experience.

Remember, seeking help isn't a sign of weakness - it's a sign of professional wisdom. After all, we advise clients to seek expert help when they need it. Isn't it time we took our own advice?

Photo: Yan Krukau via Pexels

#LegalWellness #WorkLifeBalance #LegalCommunity #Burnout

© 2025 Stefan Jurgens. All rights reserved.

Unless otherwise noted, all content on this blog is the copyright of Stefan Jurgens.